The Palestine Herald, Palestine, Texas

Opinion

April 4, 2014

MOVIE REVIEW: 'God’s Not Dead’ surprisingly effective

The emerging “faith-based” cinematic industry is slowly becoming a force to be reckoned with.  Not only are the movies they are churning out now generating modest profits, but the quality of the work is improving.  In 2006, we saw “The Ultimate Gift” and “One Night with the King,” in 2008, “Fireproof,” in 2010, “The Grace Card,” in 2011, “Seven Days in Utopia” and “Courageous.”

This year we see “God’s Not Dead” (AKA “God Isn’t Dead”).

At fictional Hadleigh University, faithful freshman Josh Wheaton is confronted with a challenge from his atheistic philosophy professor:  just affirm that God is dead, and it will improve his workload and probably his grade.  But Josh can’t do it.  

Irritated by what he sees as Josh’s rejection of his superior intellect, Professor Radisson tells Josh he will have to defend God in class; if he fails to do so adequately (a 100 percent certainty according to Radisson), he will likely fail the class.  Using logic and reason (Radisson’s own tools), Josh strives to refute Radisson’s position.  On its face, the story appears to be just a battle of the wills between diametrically opposing viewpoints.  Radisson is adamant that God doesn’t exist, and Josh cannot deny his faith; this alone would make a compelling film.

But “God’s Not Dead” offers a nuanced approach with numerous subplots: one involving an investigative reporter seeking to discredit Duck Dynasty and Newsboys, another involving a dementia- riddled woman and her two grown children, another the impact of faith on romantic relationships, still another on a Muslim student hiding her Christian faith from her father.  Underscoring all of these are the circumstances (grace?) that prevent a local pastor from going on a well-earned vacation.

Not entirely seamless, the story bounces around a bit, but the audience can see the connections, how all things are somehow related.

The ending is quite powerful and somewhat surprising: not the gushy conversion that the audience would expect, but a gritty response to the challenges of life.

As a presentation of Christian apologetics, the film tends to allow Josh to wax eloquent on the subject, and tends to reveal Radisson’s position as entirely one dimensional.  In fact, Radisson, played with blustery effect by Kevin Sorbo (TV’s “Hercules: The Legendary Journeys”) seems an absolute tyrant in his classroom as well as his personal life, and is very quick to cite his intellectual superiority.  

At first blush, this imbalance appears to challenge the plausibility requirement of any good film, but on reflection, isn’t that what most of us in reality do?  Don’t we tend to grasp at one reason/cause/position and cling tenaciously to it?  And when that one position is challenged, don’t we tend to lash out at the challenger?  Further, don’t we all like to think of ourselves as having above average intelligence (at least on subjects on which we have unshakeable opinions)? In fact, Professor Radisson is a more plausible antagonist than we see in many mainstream films today (“Winter’s Tale,” “Pompeii,” “Jack Ryan,” and “I, Frankenstein” come to mind).

On occasion, the acting is amateurish, but generally works. Contrivances in the script can beggar belief (like what is a faithful Christian doing hooking up with her atheist college professor? And why did an astute investigative reporter fail to notice that her boyfriend was a self-obsessed jerk?), yet the film is generally well written.  

While the dramatic contest between professor and student takes center stage, this film is really about how faith is truly present everywhere — in everyone’s life, whether they are Christian or not.  “God’s Not Dead” is saying that it takes a leap of faith for a person to profess ANY belief with certainty, even if that person claims not to rely on faith and denigrates those who do.  

So why do some people advocate Christianity, others atheism?  Watch “God’s Not Dead” for one possible answer.

3.0 Stars

————

1 star — Avoid this boring mess of a movie at all costs.  Reading the dictionary is more entertaining.

2 stars — If you're in the right mood or if the subject matter appeals to you, you may like this film; or it is uneven, at times entertaining and believable and at other times sophomoric.  If you've got nothing else to do, it may be worth the price of admission (at least a matinee).

3 stars — This is a generally good movie that most people will enjoy.  If you're looking for an entertaining couple of hours, spend it here and you won't be disappointed.

4 stars — Don't miss this film!  I don't care if you have time or not, make the time, because this movie is terrific.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • 7-26-simon-slaw.jpg Cooking with Simon: Stomp grapes and eat Texas food

    If you’re picking up the newspaper on Saturday, you still have a chance to come out to Sabor a Pasion and celebrate the grape harvest at the 2nd Annual Charity Grape Stomp.

    July 26, 2014 2 Photos

  • Two decades of storytelling

    For the past 20 years, I have covered everything under the sun while working as community editor at the Palestine Herald-Press. I have covered festivals, banquets, graduations, fires, wrecks, elections, giant vegetables, you name it, I probably wrote about it.

    July 26, 2014

  • At the Movies: 'Begin Again' — Fresh tale creates appeal

    Some people film big pictures.  Others do small pictures.  Writer-director John Carney makes small pictures. 

    July 26, 2014

  • IMG_1373.jpeg COOKING WITH SIMON: Summer produce brings recipe inspiration

    Chefs are always recreating their menus and finding new inspiration for recipes. People ask me how where my new ideas come from and what I do to get inspired. The answer – mowing the lawn – and, by the way, I have a lot of lawn, vineyard and fields to mow.

    July 19, 2014 3 Photos

  • Swiss Chard  & Peach Salad COOKING WITH SIMON: Garden vegetables ready to harvest

    Last month, I was invited to cook for a group of clients at a fishing lodge in Alaska. It was quite an experience – beautiful scenery, amazing salmon, halibut, and great accessibility to some of the best fishing in the world.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • watermelon COOKING WITH SIMON: Red, white and watermelon

    Happy 4th of July weekend! On every street corner the fruit of Texas is being sold from the back of old trucks and roadside produce stands.

    July 5, 2014 1 Photo

  • COLUMN: Musings about life and the pursuit of happiness

    Yesterday was July 4th, a time we celebrate independence and the truths that all men are created equal and “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights,” to quote Mr. Jefferson.

    July 5, 2014

  • MOVIE REVIEW: 22 Jump Street

    I should have known better.  Just like “Legally Blonde” and “Dumb and Dumber,” a comedy based on a premise as opposed to one based on truly funny characters merged with a clever situation should never have a sequel.

    July 3, 2014

  • 6-28--SIMON-Lamb-Sliders.jpg Cooking with Simon: Celebrate July 4th with lamb burgers

    Being born in one country and raised in another can bring a bit of confusion to one’s life. And then to find yourself living in a third country as an adult, is one reason this kiwi is all messed up.

    June 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Editor's Notebook: Kids can create their own summer fun

    Things are so different today than when I was a kid. A recent conversation with my 9-year-old son reinforced my belief.

    June 28, 2014