The Palestine Herald, Palestine, Texas

Breaking News


September 28, 2012

Ask Debra: Is Hoarding an Addiction?

PALESTINE — Question: My sister-in-law has started hoarding. She didn't used to do this. My brother is so grief-stricken over the death of their son he doesn't seem to be able to see it. I am concerned for them both and confused about what has caused her to start hoarding. Her house is getting so stacked up with stuff she's finding on sale that there's little room for the regular stuff. Is this considered an addiction, what causes it, and how can I help her?

Answer: Usually, when we talk about addictions, most people automatically think drugs, alcohol, and tobacco. However, people can be addicted to nearly anything that they allow to control them including food, caffeine, television, religion, and even hoarding. An addiction can be defined as any compulsive, repetitive behavior that can't be stopped and results in negative consequences. Often, those consequences can be financial, medical, and/or relational.

Addictions can be rooted in a chemical imbalance of the brain. However, if an addiction evolves after a tragic life experience, then often the source can be pinpointed as emotionally (or fear) driven. If your brother and sister-in-law have experienced the death of a child, then that could very likely be linked to the cause of her hoarding. Many times when people experience the loss of a loved one, they become afraid of losing anything and everything else. So they hoard. Hoarding is a repetitive, compulsive behavior that usually can't be stopped without counseling. It does have negative fallout, such as misdirecting finances for items not needed and creating a fire hazard in the home.

However, different people hoard different things. For some, it's everything on sale. For others, it's clothing or shoes. For many, it's food.

The whole idea behind hoarding is that the hoarder has lost control of an area of his/her life and is straining to regain the feeling of being in control. Because the future is uncertain and bleak, they believe that by hoarding they can prepare for the uncertainty and be in control in their future. Hoarders can hang onto the tiniest things, thinking they might need them in the future. Meanwhile, all those things stack up and take over their lives.

None of this means preparing for the future in a healthy, balanced way is unwise. But the truth is, no matter how much any of us prepares for the future, the future is in God's hands and we cannot control it. At any given moment, a natural disaster, fire, financial crisis or major robbery can wipe out almost every physical thing we've saved. Those who have a life focused on what bad things might happen and allow that fear to drive compulsive behavior often miss all the good that is happening.

The answer for your sister-in-law and all of us it to fully release control of the past, present, and future to Christ. Once this is accomplished, there is an amazing peace that descends from heaven. At that point, many addictions are well on the way to no longer having control over the individual. I remember the lines of a song by Stuart Hamblen my dad played when I was a kid, “I know not what the future holds, but I know who holds the future. It's a secret known only to Him.”

Your sister-in-law needs prayer and counseling. Certainly pray for her, but also pray that the Lord will open up an opportunity for you to talk to her about her hoarding. Go ahead and plan ahead. Find a counselor you trust in your church or in the community you can recommend when God opens up the opportunity to talk with her.

Furthermore, your brother and sister-in-law both need a support group to help them through their grief. I recommend that you also find out what's available in that area as well and  be ready to gently direct them.


The author of 54 books, Debra White Smith holds an M.A. from U.T. and is the featured relationship specialist on the Fox News Radio Show, “Plain Jane Wisdom.” She and her husband, Daniel, co-pastor Palestine Church of the Nazarene. For more information, visit Got a problem? E-mail Debra at


Text Only
  • 7-26-simon-slaw.jpg Cooking with Simon: Stomp grapes and eat Texas food

    If you’re picking up the newspaper on Saturday, you still have a chance to come out to Sabor a Pasion and celebrate the grape harvest at the 2nd Annual Charity Grape Stomp.

    July 26, 2014 2 Photos

  • Two decades of storytelling

    For the past 20 years, I have covered everything under the sun while working as community editor at the Palestine Herald-Press. I have covered festivals, banquets, graduations, fires, wrecks, elections, giant vegetables, you name it, I probably wrote about it.

    July 26, 2014

  • At the Movies: 'Begin Again' — Fresh tale creates appeal

    Some people film big pictures.  Others do small pictures.  Writer-director John Carney makes small pictures. 

    July 26, 2014

  • IMG_1373.jpeg COOKING WITH SIMON: Summer produce brings recipe inspiration

    Chefs are always recreating their menus and finding new inspiration for recipes. People ask me how where my new ideas come from and what I do to get inspired. The answer – mowing the lawn – and, by the way, I have a lot of lawn, vineyard and fields to mow.

    July 19, 2014 3 Photos

  • Swiss Chard  & Peach Salad COOKING WITH SIMON: Garden vegetables ready to harvest

    Last month, I was invited to cook for a group of clients at a fishing lodge in Alaska. It was quite an experience – beautiful scenery, amazing salmon, halibut, and great accessibility to some of the best fishing in the world.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • watermelon COOKING WITH SIMON: Red, white and watermelon

    Happy 4th of July weekend! On every street corner the fruit of Texas is being sold from the back of old trucks and roadside produce stands.

    July 5, 2014 1 Photo

  • COLUMN: Musings about life and the pursuit of happiness

    Yesterday was July 4th, a time we celebrate independence and the truths that all men are created equal and “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights,” to quote Mr. Jefferson.

    July 5, 2014

  • MOVIE REVIEW: 22 Jump Street

    I should have known better.  Just like “Legally Blonde” and “Dumb and Dumber,” a comedy based on a premise as opposed to one based on truly funny characters merged with a clever situation should never have a sequel.

    July 3, 2014

  • 6-28--SIMON-Lamb-Sliders.jpg Cooking with Simon: Celebrate July 4th with lamb burgers

    Being born in one country and raised in another can bring a bit of confusion to one’s life. And then to find yourself living in a third country as an adult, is one reason this kiwi is all messed up.

    June 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Editor's Notebook: Kids can create their own summer fun

    Things are so different today than when I was a kid. A recent conversation with my 9-year-old son reinforced my belief.

    June 28, 2014