The Palestine Herald, Palestine, Texas


September 14, 2012


Have you ever noticed that movies about authors of astronomically well-written cutting edge books are in themselves not particularly well written? For instance, it is apparent that the writers of the 2007 KeiraKnightley vehicle “Atonement” didn’t really know what that word meant. The 2012 Bradley Cooper vehicle “The Words” suffers from a similar ailment: although populated with grandiose imagery, the actual words used in the picture are rather mundane. I suppose that’s the irony the producers wished to convey: that mere words are incapable of capturing the human heart.

In an attempt at labyrinthine story-telling, the movie opens with celebrated author Clay reading excerpts from his new novel to a rapt audience. The story he reads tells of Rory, a struggling young writer who finds a fifty year old novel manuscript that reveals to him his own inadequacies as a writer.  He publishes the novel as his own and it is an instant best seller. Then an Old Man accuses him of stealing his novel and proceeds to tell the history of the writing of that novel. Overcome with a stricken conscience, Rory offers to remove his nameand surrender all proceeds to the Old Man who rejects that gesture.  An enthusiastic listener to Clay’s story, Daniella, attempts to get Clay to reveal how things are finally resolved, but Clay instead asks her to finish the story.

Sadly, the script for “The Words” is one of its weaknesses. The intricate weaving of three separate tales is not seamless, and in fact, the words we hear Clay read are, to be honest, boring, and contain all the passive voice errors our Freshman English teachers taught us to avoid.  Interestingly, the words of Rory’s/the Old Man’s novel are never heard or seen, merely their impact on the reader; in fact, we are not sure if the story the Old Man tells Rory is the actual plotline of the novel or not—it seems the actual words are not relevant. The audience hears no great dialogue.

Ironicallyin a picture “about” the power of words, the outstanding feature of the film is the cinematography.  Directors Brian Klugman (“Cloverfield”) and Lee Sternthal while fairly young and inexperienced, are wise enough to let Cinematographer Antonio Calvache(“In the Bedroom”) evoke through lighting and texture three incredibly intimate worlds.  The scenes of Clay and Daniella are sterile, cold, and smooth.  Those of Rory and his wife Dora and the stalking Old Man are claustrophobic in intensity, with lush foliage, brooding shadows and powerful colors all surrounding and overwhelming Rory with passion. The scenes the Old Man tells of post-World War II France have a patina of nostalgia about them, slightly faded, faintly sepia-toned with the innocence of remembrance.

Because dialogue is so bland, the emotions must be written on the faces of the actors.  Dennis Quaid (“Footloose”) as Clay is craggy and cynical; Olivia Wilde (“The Change-Up”) plays Daniella as a college co-ed on the make, supremely confident of her good looks andsure of her intellectual superiority.  Jeremy Irons (“Kingdom of Heaven”) portrays the wizened Old Man, his trademark scratchy voicesadly emotionless most of the time.  Bradley Cooper (“The Hangover”) has the most screen time as Rory, registering appropriate degrees of angst and regret.  Zoe Saldana (“Star Trek”) is Rory’s wife Dora, a woman who hopes to be his muse but is unable to overcome her disappointment in his failures.

“The Words” is ultimately a disappointing film simply because it is so poorly written, with sketchy dialogue and only mildly interesting characters. The premise is good, but the film fails to deliver on a number of levels, other than to leave the audience with a lingering sense of sadness. Still, it is worth watching simply for the images Antonio Calvache etches on the screen, vibrant with texture and nuance.

2.5 Stars

Text Only
  • 7-26-simon-slaw.jpg Cooking with Simon: Stomp grapes and eat Texas food

    If you’re picking up the newspaper on Saturday, you still have a chance to come out to Sabor a Pasion and celebrate the grape harvest at the 2nd Annual Charity Grape Stomp.

    July 26, 2014 2 Photos

  • Two decades of storytelling

    For the past 20 years, I have covered everything under the sun while working as community editor at the Palestine Herald-Press. I have covered festivals, banquets, graduations, fires, wrecks, elections, giant vegetables, you name it, I probably wrote about it.

    July 26, 2014

  • At the Movies: 'Begin Again' — Fresh tale creates appeal

    Some people film big pictures.  Others do small pictures.  Writer-director John Carney makes small pictures. 

    July 26, 2014

  • IMG_1373.jpeg COOKING WITH SIMON: Summer produce brings recipe inspiration

    Chefs are always recreating their menus and finding new inspiration for recipes. People ask me how where my new ideas come from and what I do to get inspired. The answer – mowing the lawn – and, by the way, I have a lot of lawn, vineyard and fields to mow.

    July 19, 2014 3 Photos

  • Swiss Chard  & Peach Salad COOKING WITH SIMON: Garden vegetables ready to harvest

    Last month, I was invited to cook for a group of clients at a fishing lodge in Alaska. It was quite an experience – beautiful scenery, amazing salmon, halibut, and great accessibility to some of the best fishing in the world.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • watermelon COOKING WITH SIMON: Red, white and watermelon

    Happy 4th of July weekend! On every street corner the fruit of Texas is being sold from the back of old trucks and roadside produce stands.

    July 5, 2014 1 Photo

  • COLUMN: Musings about life and the pursuit of happiness

    Yesterday was July 4th, a time we celebrate independence and the truths that all men are created equal and “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights,” to quote Mr. Jefferson.

    July 5, 2014

  • MOVIE REVIEW: 22 Jump Street

    I should have known better.  Just like “Legally Blonde” and “Dumb and Dumber,” a comedy based on a premise as opposed to one based on truly funny characters merged with a clever situation should never have a sequel.

    July 3, 2014

  • 6-28--SIMON-Lamb-Sliders.jpg Cooking with Simon: Celebrate July 4th with lamb burgers

    Being born in one country and raised in another can bring a bit of confusion to one’s life. And then to find yourself living in a third country as an adult, is one reason this kiwi is all messed up.

    June 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Editor's Notebook: Kids can create their own summer fun

    Things are so different today than when I was a kid. A recent conversation with my 9-year-old son reinforced my belief.

    June 28, 2014